The story
Apparently after My Old Aunt Sally, the title of a blackface minstrel song written by Dan Emmett in 1843.
First known use, by meaning
- from 19th c. A traditional game in which balls are thrown to break the pipe in the mouth of a wooden figurine resembling an old woman.
- from 19th c. A figure drawing criticism or ridicule, especially when prejudiced or unwarranted.
- from 19th c. an object set up to invite such criticism
Etymology from Wiktionary, CC BY-SA 4.0.