Amish bus driver rule

proper noun

The notion that one who refuses to perform a job's duties cannot demand employment in that job.

Meanings

proper noun
  1. idiomaticneologismThe notion that one who refuses to perform a job's duties cannot demand employment in that job.

    finally - it's the same as the amish bus driver rule.

    2009 April 1, Xelene_Hecate, “Dunkin' Donuts Pulls Franchise From Muslim Who Refuses To Sell Pork [comment]”, in The Huffington Post, retrieved 17 Mar 2014
    5 more examples

    In other words, Bush broke what I have always called the “Amish bus driver” rule. If your religion requires you not to drive, cool beans, free country — but then you can‘t get hired to be a bus driver if your religion won't let you drive the bus.

    2009 February 27, The Rachel Maddow Show, Rachel Maddow (actor), via MSNBC

    Rachel Maddow calls it the Amish Bus Driver Rule. If your beliefs dictate that you cannot do the job you’re being paid to do, then you have no right being in that job.

    2009 April 26, Karla, “Pharmacists sue for right to deny medication [comment]”, in The Good Atheist, archived from the original on 04 Mar 2016

    The Amish Bus Driver Rule goes like this: If you’re Amish, and therefore have religious convictions against internal combustion engines, then you have disqualified yourself for employment as a bus driver.

    2010 October 12, DrRich, “Medical Ethics and the Amish Bus Driver Rule”, in The Covert Rationing Blog, retrieved 17 Mar 2014

    Amish Bus Driver rule. (If you refuse to do some job, you can’t demand to be hired for it.)

    2011 June 28, Vystrix Nexoth, “New York Town Clerk: If Gays Can Marry, I Can’t Do My Job [comment]”, in Friendly Atheist, retrieved 17 Mar 2014

    Of course he should be able to stick to his beliefs. He just can’t be an actor if his faith won’t allow him to act. Amish bus driver rule in action.

    2011 August 1, deconstructingglee, “The Glee Project: Sexuality (aka Christians are ruining my Glee) [comment]”, in Deconstructing Glee, retrieved 17 Mar 2014

Origin

Coined by American television host Rachel Maddow prior to 2009, evoking the common knowledge that Amish communities often prohibit motor vehicles and thus a member of such would be disallowed from driving a bus.

Full word history & related roots →
Cite this entry
APA

Amish bus driver rule. (n.d.). In WatkinsX Dictionary. Retrieved November 5, 2026, from https://dictionary.watkinsx.com/word/Amish%20bus%20driver%20rule

MLA

“Amish bus driver rule.” WatkinsX Dictionary, https://dictionary.watkinsx.com/word/Amish%20bus%20driver%20rule. Accessed November 5, 2026.

Chicago

WatkinsX Dictionary, s.v. “Amish bus driver rule,” accessed November 5, 2026, https://dictionary.watkinsx.com/word/Amish%20bus%20driver%20rule.

Source: Amish bus driver rule on Wiktionary, CC BY-SA 4.0.