fair cop

plural fair cops

1. A justifiable or reasonable capture or apprehension; also, broadly, a just or inescapable accusation.

   hector. No, by thunder! It was not a fair cop. We were four to one.

   1919, George Bernard Shaw, Heartbreak House, Great Catherine, and Playlets of the War, Brentano's

   5 more examples

   Several other witnesses gave corroborative evidence, and a constable who helped to arrest the prisoners stated that one of them, on being taken into custody, said: “Ah, well, this is a fair cop.”

   1891, Montagu Stephen Williams, Later Leaves: Being the Further Reminiscences of Montagu Williams, Q. C., Macmillan and Co.

   ‘A fair cop,’ murmured Ladd feebly. ‘I give in, mister; it’s a fair cop.’

   1900, William Pett Ridge, A Breaker of Laws, Harper & Brothers

   Inspector: I shall have to ask you to accompany me to the station. Mr. Hilton: It’s a fair cop.

   1969 November 23, “Crunchy Frog”, in Monty Python's Flying Circus, season 1, episode 6

   Okay, it’s a fair cop. Claire’s not a Bible scholar, and neither am I. It wasn’t Gideon, it was Jephthah (Judges 12).

   1999, Diana Gabaldon, The Outlandish Companion, Delacorte Press

   The chap opposite seems to be trying to pull a fast one, and having seen the guard is trying to buy a ticket online... but doesn't succeed. The guard helpfully sells him one, but not quite at the price of one purchased in advance. In fairness he doesn't kick off, nor does the guard treat him like some common criminal. It's a fair cop - or should that be a fare cop?

   2024 April 17, “Rural railways: do they deliver?”, in RAIL, number 1007, page 57