fake fan

plural fake fans · plural fake fen

1. alternativedatedderogatoryslangsometimeslifestyleAlternative form of fakefan.

   The culprits responsible for these mags are the former fan and most unrelenting feudist of all times, William S Sykora; the juvenile and semi-illiterate James V Taurasi and the commercially minded fake fan, Sam Moskowitz.

   1939 September, Donald Wollheim, “'New Fandom' Versus True Fandom”, in MSA Bulletin, number 1, page 4

   2 more examples

   Phrase coined about 1940, applied to Jack Weidenbeck, who roomed with fans and enjoyed their company but shunned all responsibility in fan doings and institutions. Generally speaking, one who hangs around fans but takes no active part in fan affairs, and may not read fantasy. Fans are, after all, at least theoretically fantasy enthusiasts; fake fans are fandom enthusiasts. They don't read prozines. (Sometimes they don't even read fanzines.) They don't remember vast numbers of insignificant details about fantasy stories and their authors illustrators and publishers. They don't collect books or proz. Fake fans do not have the haggard look that is the mark of the true fan trying to keep abreast of the latest developments in stfdom. And there are some fans who like to describe themselves as fakefans to symbolize disinterest, but their continued fanac belies them.

   1959, Richard "Dick" Harris Eney, Fancyclopedia II, Fake Fan

   Writers, editors, artists, fans, fan-editors -- even the 'fake fans' who never read the stuff -- have a strong commonality of interests, stereotypes, gossip, and even jargon. Fanzines, talks, panels, the 'pro' play -- all are crammed with private jokes and allusions that make very little sense to the outsider.

   1960 January, P. Schuyler Miller, Astounding Science Fiction, volume 64, number 5

2. derogatorySomeone who falsely claims to be a fan.

   I just thought I would let you know that a bandwagon fan is a fake fan.

   1998 September 26, Mike C, “Re: Is Kordell Dumber Than A Box Of Rocks?”, in rec.arts.sf.fandom (Usenet), message-ID <360D3290.404D2BE4@954access.net>

   1 more example

   For example, your potential date says she is an avid football fan (because one of your photos had you in an NFL cap). Good observation on her part spotting the cap, but you can stop the fake fan in her tracks by sacking her attempted pass at you. During preliminary discussions, bring up the topic of football and mention perhaps (keeping in line with fishing theme) that the Miami Dolphins are your favorite team, but they just haven't been the same since quarterback David Hasselhoff retired for a television career on Baywatch.

   2009, Julian Barrie, Chasing Women Without Leaving Your Seat, →ISBN, page 56